
Fouquet's New York
Best for travelers who want Parisian brasserie dining, Art Deco design, and an adults-focused spa experience in Lower Manhattan.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Fouquet's New York is a Parisian, Art Deco–inspired five-star hotel in Tribeca with 97 rooms, a full spa and an indoor hydrotherapy pool; read this if you want polished French dining and a design-forward downtown stay. The Whitby Hotel is a colorful, Firmdale-designed five-star boutique in Midtown (18 West 56th Street); read this if you prefer playful, apartment-like rooms close to Central Park and Midtown attractions.
Updated · about 3.2 km apart

Best for travelers who want Parisian brasserie dining, Art Deco design, and an adults-focused spa experience in Lower Manhattan.

Best for guests who want bright, boutique Firmdale interiors and a central Midtown location within easy walking distance of Central Park and Rockefeller Center.
When Fouquet's New York wins: choose Fouquet's for French brasserie dining by Pierre Gagnaire, a full-service Spa Diane Barrière with a heated indoor hydrotherapy pool, and an intimate Art Deco atmosphere in Tribeca.
When The Whitby Hotel wins: pick The Whitby if you want a colorful Firmdale-style boutique in Midtown close to Top of the Rock and Central Park, with a playful room palette and strong concierge/service options.
Bottom line: both are five-star, design-led boutique hotels; pick Fouquet's for Parisian dining and a dedicated spa/pool program, pick The Whitby for midtown convenience and Firmdale's distinctive colorful look.
| Category | Fouquet's New York | The Whitby Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Parisian, Art Deco–inspired luxury with refined brasserie and speakeasy venues | Colorful, playful Firmdale boutique luxury in Midtown |
| Location (neighborhood) | Tribeca — Lower Manhattan, near Hudson River Park and SoHo | Midtown, steps from Top of the Rock and Central Park |
| Size | Eight-story property with 97 rooms and suites | Not published |
| Room types (sample) | Deluxe Room; Junior Suite; Tribeca Terrace Suite; Hudson View Corner Suite | Deluxe Top Floor; Junior Terrace Suite; The Whitby Suite; Corner Terrace Suite |
| Pools | Heated indoor hydrotherapy pool in Spa Diane Barrière (year-round; age rules apply) | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Brasserie Fouquet's, Élysée's (courtyard), Titsou Bar speakeasy, Le Vaux Rooftop | On-site restaurant(s) and bar listed; 24-hour room service and breakfast options available |
| Spa & fitness | Spa Diane Barrière with five treatment rooms, sauna, steam room; DOGPOUND Fitness Center (Technogym) open 24 hours | Spa and massage services and a fitness center listed; salon services available |
| Known for | Parisian-brasserie dining, Art Deco interiors by Martin Brudnizki, an adults-focused spa with hydrotherapy pool | Firmdale's signature colorful design, Midtown location, strong concierge and boutique-hotel service |
| Family / age policy | All ages welcome; spa and pool access restricted to adults (18+) except accompanied teens in some cases | Family/child friendly; not adults-only |
| Nearby highlights | Hudson River Park, One World Trade Center, SoHo | Top of the Rock (0.51 km), Central Park (0.67 km), Broadway (0.98 km) |
Fouquet's New York sits in Tribeca, a Lower Manhattan neighborhood that mixes historic industrial buildings with waterfront access.
Fouquet's places you closer to downtown attractions and the Hudson waterfront.
The Whitby Hotel is on West 56th Street in Midtown, putting Midtown attractions and Central Park within easy reach.
The Whitby is a practical base for sightseeing in Midtown and museum/theater districts.
Fouquet's offers 97 rooms and suites designed by Martin Brudnizki with Art Deco touches and Toile de Jouy fabrics.
Rooms emphasize Parisian Art Deco details and downtown character across a 97-room house.
The Whitby’s rooms reflect Firmdale’s colorful, residential aesthetic across a range of room and suite names.
The Whitby favors playful, apartment-like rooms with varied layouts and terrace options.
Fouquet's is centered on French and Mediterranean dining with venues recreated from the Fouquet's Paris concept.
Dining at Fouquet's is a major draw for guests who want formal French brasserie and speakeasy-style cocktails.
The Whitby offers on-site dining and bar options plus 24-hour room service and flexible breakfast choices.
The Whitby delivers the typical Firmdale combination of comfortable dining and strong in-house service.
Fouquet's New York features a heated indoor hydrotherapy pool inside Spa Diane Barrière.
If an on-site indoor hydrotherapy pool matters, Fouquet's provides a dedicated, adults-focused facility.
The Whitby Hotel supplier listing mentions fitness, massage and salon services but does not publish an on-site pool.
The Whitby focuses on boutique rooms and wellness services; if a pool is essential, check with the hotel first.
Fouquet's mixes a full-service spa and a 24-hour DOGPOUND Fitness Center with nightlife venues on property.
Fouquet's pairs a substantial spa program with late-night drinking options in an Art Deco setting.
The Whitby lists massage, salon and fitness facilities and houses an on-site bar for evening drinks.
The Whitby covers basic wellness and nightlife needs with a Midtown concierge ready for theater and museum plans.

Fouquet's — Brasserie Fouquet's and Élysée's plus Titsou Bar deliver a cohesive French/Mediterranean dining program.

The Whitby — steps from Top of the Rock, Central Park and Fifth Avenue shopping.

Fouquet's — Spa Diane Barrière includes a heated indoor hydrotherapy pool and five treatment rooms.

The Whitby — Firmdale’s signature colorful and residential-style rooms and suites.
The Whitby Hotel is much closer to Central Park (about 0.67 km to Central Park from the Whitby listing).
Fouquet's New York has a heated indoor hydrotherapy pool in its spa; The Whitby’s supplier listing does not publish an on-site pool.
No — both properties welcome families; Fouquet's restricts spa/pool access by age in order to preserve a quieter atmosphere.
The Whitby — its Midtown address puts Broadway theaters, Top of the Rock and Fifth Avenue within easy walking distance.
Explore how Fouquet's New York stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·